Saturday, November 14, 2009

Sermon for the 2nd Last Sunday in the Church Year (One Year LSB)


Come, Inherit the Kingdom
Matthew 25:31-46
2nd Last Sunday in the Church Year, 2009
Peace Lutheran Church
Alma, Michigan
Pastor Jonathon Bakker

            Grace to you and Peace from God our Father and from the Lord, Jesus Christ, Amen.       The text for our consideration on this 2nd Last Sunday in the Church Year comes from the Gospel of St. Matthew, which was just read.  You may be seated.

"When the Son of Man comes in His glory, and all the holy angels with Him, then He will sit on the throne of His glory.  "All the nations will be gathered before Him, and He will separate them one from another, as a shepherd divides his sheep from the goats.  "And He will set the sheep on His right hand, but the goats on the left.  "Then the King will say to those on His right hand, 'Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world:  'for I was hungry and you gave Me food; I was thirsty and you gave Me drink; I was a stranger and you took Me in;  'I was naked and you clothed Me; I was sick and you visited Me; I was in prison and you came to Me.'  "Then the righteous will answer Him, saying, 'Lord, when did we see You hungry and feed You, or thirsty and give You drink?  'When did we see You a stranger and take You in, or naked and clothe You?  'Or when did we see You sick, or in prison, and come to You?'  "And the King will answer and say to them, 'Assuredly, I say to you, inasmuch as you did it to one of the least of these My brethren, you did it to Me.'  "Then He will also say to those on the left hand, 'Depart from Me, you cursed, into the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels:  'for I was hungry and you gave Me no food; I was thirsty and you gave Me no drink;  'I was a stranger and you did not take Me in, naked and you did not clothe Me, sick and in prison and you did not visit Me.'  "Then they also will answer Him, saying, 'Lord, when did we see You hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or sick or in prison, and did not minister to You?'  "Then He will answer them, saying, 'Assuredly, I say to you, inasmuch as you did not do it to one of the least of these, you did not do it to Me.'  "And these will go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into eternal life."

This is the text.

            Dear brothers and sisters in Christ, most of the time when Jesus tells his disciples a parable, they require an explanation.  In fact, most times when Jesus speaks, his disciples require explanation; otherwise, they do not understand Jesus.  Today’s Gospel reading is the last of his Parables of the Kingdom, where Jesus teaches the disciples about the kingdom of heaven, and specifically, about the coming judgment.

            This parable is different from the other Parables of the Kingdom.  The first parable in this chapter of Matthew tells of the ten virgins who were awaiting the coming of the bridegroom.  Five were wise and had extra oil for their lamps to last until the bridegroom would return.  The other five were foolish, bringing only the oil they had in their lamps.  The foolish virgins had to rush to the vendors to buy more oil, and ended up missing the bridegroom when he came.  The door was shut to them and the bridegroom said that he did not know them.  The wedding took place, but those who did not take care to be ready for the bridegroom missed it.  The disciples, and all of us, were to watch, for we know neither the day nor the hour in which the Son of Man is coming. 

            The second parable tells of the lord who travelled to a far country, called three of his servants to him, and gave them responsibility over some of his treasure.  One received five talents, another received two talents, and the third received one talent.  The first two engaged in trade and doubled their holdings, but the last was afraid and instead hid it in the ground.  When their lord returned to settle accounts, he was pleased with the first two, telling them that they would be rulers over greater things, and to enter into the joy of their lord.  With the last servant, however, the lord was not pleased.  This servant was so afraid and lazy that he did not even invest his lord’s money with the bankers, so that at the very least he could have some interest to show for his lord’s trust in him.  His lord took the talent from the lazy servant and cast that servant into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.

            Today’s Gospel lesson is the third parable, and unlike the others, it requires little explanation.  For instance, none of us should be surprised that Jesus is going to return in glory and will sit upon a throne in his glory.  We expect that from the Son of Man.  We even look forward to it when we find ourselves suffering in this world.  Two weeks ago was All Saints’ Day, the day we commemorate those of us who have fallen asleep in the faith and who now rest with their Lord.  We suffer when our loved ones are hurt, when they fall ill, and especially when they die.  We look to the coming of the Son of Man because that means the end of this earthly suffering.

            The parable goes on as Jesus tells of the coming judgment.  All of the nations will be gathered before the throne, and they will be separated, one from the other, as a shepherd divides his sheep from the goats.  The sheep will be gathered at his right and the goats will be gathered at his left.  This too is quite clear.  To the sheep, the King will say, ‘Come, you blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.’  To the goats, however, he will say, ‘Depart from me, you cursed, in the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels.’  The sheep will have everlasting life, and the goats will have everlasting death.

            The rest of the parable, however, is a bit more difficult.  Jesus goes on to describe the sheep and the goats.  The sheep feed the hungry, quench the thirsty, and take in strangers.  They clothe the naked, visit the sick, and come to those in prison.  The goats do otherwise.  The reason this parable becomes difficult is because we want to see ourselves as sheep, but we cannot help thinking that the description of the goats is more accurate of ourselves.  Is Jesus’ accounting of qualifications for the sheep and the goats some kind of eternal checklist, a set of goals for us to accomplish before he returns?  Perhaps we are to perform as many of those things as we can to tip our scales from ‘goat-hood’ to ‘sheep-hood’?  The answer is no, of course.  Neither of those solutions fits the problem, because in both cases we are looking at the wrong thing.

            The day is surely drawing near, dear friends, when God’s Son will return.  The dead will be raised, and each of us will stand before the judgment seat.  Thankfully, however, we will not be concerned about the things we have done or have not done, for the judge does not look at us.  The king, Jesus, does not judge us based on ourselves, otherwise none of us qualifies as a sheep.  The conditions are impossible.  The judgment of God, however, does not fall upon us.  The parable also includes these words.  ‘Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.’

            What else has happened from the foundation of the world?  John teaches us in the book of Revelation that the Lamb has been slain from the foundation of the world.  In other words, Christ has been crucified from the foundation of the world, and in that crucifixion, he has redeemed humanity from sin.  The wrath of God’s judgment has been delivered to the Son on the cross from the foundation of the world.  The penalty has been paid and the ransom for humanity has been satisfied.  The fact that Jesus rose from the dead on the third day is proof that his death means life for those who are in him.

            That cross, dear friends, is where we are to look, so that we do not need to wonder whether we are sheep or goats.  All of us are sinful goats by nature, but the Good Shepherd laid down his life to make us his sheep.  Instead of thinking about what we have done or what we have not done to be sure that we are counted as sheep, Jesus demonstrates that he has taken our ‘goat-hood’, our sinfulness, upon himself, and replaced it in us with his ‘sheep-hood’, that is, his righteousness, his forgiveness, his life.

            We do not do the righteous things, but Jesus is the righteous one.  Even though we have failed to be that which were created to be in the Garden of Eden, God sent his only Son to fulfill all righteousness in our place.  When the King looks at us in that day, he will not say that we left him naked and without clothing.  He will instead see that He has given us his own clothing in baptism; a white robe of righteousness.  He will not say that we have not given him food or water.  He will instead see that he has fed us not only our daily bread, but he has also given us the very best food and the very best drink in his body and blood.  We will not be condemned for neglecting him when he was a stranger.  Instead, he will see that he has taken us in when we were not only his strangers – we were his enemies.  We were also the sick ones.  He looked beyond any physical illness that might have been ailing us, and visited himself upon us, healing our most dreadful ailment – death from sin – and replacing it with eternal life.  We were the ones in prison to whom he came, and he released us from our selfish bondage of sin so that we might love him, have faith in him, and love and serve our neighbours as well. 

            On account of Jesus’ giving of himself to us, we are not the goats that our sinful natures try to tell us that we are, we are instead his sheep, and he has made us that way.  So come, dear friends, blessed of the Father in heaven, and inherit the Kingdom which has been prepared for you from the foundation of the world.  The sufferings of this world will be over, and our Good Shepherd will have made us free to dwell at his right hand in his pasture, forever.

            To Christ alone be all the glory, both now and forever.  Amen.
            The peace of God that passes all understanding keep your hearts and minds through Christ Jesus our Lord.  Amen.

Friday, November 13, 2009

Sermon for the 22nd Sunday after Trinity

The Forgiven
Matthew 18:23-35
22nd Sunday after Trinity, 2009
Peace Lutheran Church
Sandusky, Michigan
Pastor Jonathon Bakker

Grace to you and peace from God our Father and from the Lord, Jesus Christ, amen. The Holy Scripture for our consideration this day is the Gospel reading from St. Matthew.

"Therefore the kingdom of heaven is like a certain king who wanted to settle accounts with his servants. And when he had begun to settle accounts, one was brought to him who owed him ten thousand talents. But as he was not able to pay, his master commanded that he be sold, with his wife and children and all that he had, and that payment be made. The servant therefore fell down before him, saying, ‘Master, have patience with me, and I will pay you all.’ Then the master of that servant was moved with compassion, released him, and forgave him the debt. “But that servant went out and found one of his fellow servants who owed him a hundred denarii; and he laid hands on him and took him by the throat, saying, ‘Pay me what you owe!’ So his fellow servant fell down at his feet and begged him, saying, ‘Have patience with me, and I will pay you all.’ And he would not, but went and threw him into prison till he should pay the debt. So when his fellow servants saw what had been done, they were very grieved, and came and told their master all that had been done. Then his master, after he had called him, said to him, ‘You wicked servant! I forgave you all that debt because you begged me. Should you not also have had compassion on your fellow servant, just as I had pity on you?’ And his master was angry, and delivered him to the torturers until he should pay all that was due to him. “So my heavenly Father also will do to you if each of you, from his heart, does not forgive his brother his trespasses.”

Dear brothers and sisters in Christ, this is an alarming Gospel to hear because it offers no hope to those who cannot forgive others. It gives an uncomfortable thrust to the 5th petition of the Lord’s Prayer, because we do not want God to actually forgive us as we have forgiven others. If our forgiveness of others is to be the standard by which God measures his forgiveness for us, we might as well present ourselves to the torturers of debtors’ prison right now and be done with it, just like the unforgiving servant in the Gospel. Though we strive to forgive and forget like the king in Jesus’ parable, we often find ourselves holding on to grudges, old and new.

Today’s Gospel does not include it, but Jesus’ words are actually a response to a question asked two verses earlier in this chapter of Matthew. Peter approached Jesus and asked, ‘Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me, and I forgive him? Up to seven times?’ And Jesus responded, ‘I do not say to you, up to seven times, but up to seventy times seven.’ And, if that was not quite clear, our Lord goes on to speak the parable of our Gospel reading to illustrate what he means by such forgiveness.

Now, Peter didn’t ask this question out of the blue – there was a reason behind his inquiry. He had been listening to the Lord throughout his ministry and had grasped many important facts. Forgiveness, for instance, is not just a one time action, and moral perfection is not possible for sinful people. He also understood the implications of that fifth petition from the Lord’s Prayer. Yet he had also just heard Jesus speak earlier in this chapter of Matthew about restoring, and in some drastic cases, removing the unrepentant from the church. Peter logically concluded that forgiveness must have its limits, and so he asked Jesus what those limits were.

Now, what Peter really wanted to know, was what was the least number of times he had to forgive his brother to still be acceptable in God’s sight. The answer is obvious to us – there is no limit to how much we ought to forgive one another. Our Lord could have simply said that, but it would have ignored the deeper problem: the hardness of Peter’s heart which led him to ask that question in the first place.

Think about it. When a child asks their parents how much homework they must do before they can visit their friends, or when someone asks how much beer they can drink before they’ve had too many, or even when someone wonders how much work they really need to do to keep the boss happy, they are all after the same thing. They are taking a lowest common denominator approach to questions that should really be asked from a different perspective; from a perspective of love.

Consider it this way: have you ever wondered how many times you must hug or kiss your husband or wife in a month before they know you really love them? Or have you ever wondered how many times you have to tell your children that you love them for them to believe you? Of course not – you do all of those things and more for the people you love, for those God has placed into your lives. You don’t just tell your children you love them; you go and watch their team is playing, you help them with their homework, and you teach them the life lessons you’ve learned. You don’t just hug and kiss your spouse and hope that’s enough for them to know you love them; you fold the laundry, you cook dinner, fix the car, and get up in the middle of the night to make sure the front door is really locked.

Asking what’s the least you have to do so that your family knows you love them sounds almost absurd to our ears – we don’t do the things we do for our families because we hope that they will finally realize that we love them; we do all of those things and more because we love them. Who keeps count of hugs and kisses? Who keeps count of saying, ‘I love you.’ You don’t need a Law from God to tell you to love your children; you love your children because they’re your children.

Love is the fulfillment of the Law, but love was not behind Peter’s question just before the Gospel reading. Peter wanted to know the minimum number of times he had to forgive his neighbor before his sins were to be held against him. Peter was searching for the limits of love, but for Jesus, however, love has no limit. He says seventy times seven times, but then goes on to show just how pointless it is to measure and count when it comes to forgiveness – when it comes to love.

The man who had a debt of ten thousand talents is like Peter – he appealed to the king for the forgiveness of an enormous debt. Ten thousand Talents is comparable to a billion dollars today – it was an utterly insurmountable debt that the man could never repay even if he, his children, and grandchildren worked every hour of every day for the rest of their lives. The king who forgives that debt – and truly no earthly king could ever afford to forgive that debt – is like Jesus who forgives our sins. The man in the parable, forgiven by the king, had clearly missed the point of that forgiveness. He chased down someone who owed him 100 denarii – a hefty sum to be sure – somewhere in the neighborhood of ten-to-fifteen thousand dollars, but not an insurmountable debt for a man and his family. Instead of showing love to this man and forgiving that debt as he had been forgiven, he showed no mercy and demanded full payment. When his debtor could not pay and begged forgiveness, he threw him into the debtor’s prison until the debt could be worked off. It was particularly cruel, considering the great mercy of the king in erasing his own debt, which was incomparably greater than this little one. When the king discovered the way his forgiven servant had handled the situation he was furious – anyone who had received such love and did not likewise show love others, even in a comparatively small way, surely did not appreciate or even understand the greater love shown to them in the first place. When the King caught up with him it was clear what would happen: he would be delivered by the king into the hands of the torturers of debtors’ prison, where would stay until he paid his debt in full.

Jesus’ then ends the parable with these words, ‘So my heavenly Father also will do to you if each of you, from his heart, does not forgive his brother his trespasses.’ Peter’s question had to do with limiting forgiveness. Having just heard the parameters for the discipline and removal of the unrepentant from the fellowship of the church, it is possible he was looking for the means by which he could exercise that discipline and removal over the other disciples and over others who followed Jesus. What Peter did not realize, just like anyone who wants to lord power over others in the church does not realize, is that punishment and judgment are the alien works of God, foreign to his nature. He will do those things when he must, but God’s chief work is to give life, and to give it eternally. This he did by sending his Son in the flesh to bear our sin and be our Savior on the cross, and this he continues to do by granting and strengthening faith in his Son by the power of the Spirit through the Means of Grace.

Peter got the message, or at least we can surmise as much from his own writings and the Scriptural accounts of his life after this point in the Gospels and Acts. He may have been a little overzealous at some points in his future, especially during the arrest and trial of our Lord, but he never again sought to use forgiveness as leverage over others. Peter was the one who was given to feed and tend Jesus’ sheep.

Friends, we too must get this message – there is no room in our Lord’s church for holding grudges and hardening our hearts against one another. Remember the love shown to us by our King, Jesus Christ, when our debt of sin was and is beyond the possibility of us repaying it. God does not love us with a checklist, working continually toward the point at which he will withdraw his gracious love and mercy from us – he loves us without conditions or limits, and through the Holy Spirit he provides the means by which he forgives us all our trespasses: he gives us faith in Jesus Christ, his Son.

Forgiving others is, therefore, no chore from God by which we make ourselves righteous in his sight; forgiving others is what we do in the church both to other Christians and the world. God doesn’t think better of you or me individually because we forgive others so many times – we can never forgive enough to make ourselves even with God. Rather, he rejoices with all of heaven when one sinner repents of his sins and receives forgiveness as a believer.

So, we need not listen to Jesus’ words this morning with fear; instead we can rejoice that our debt of ten thousand talents has been forgiven, and that God’s love for us in his Son is without limit.

To Christ alone be all the glory, forever and ever, amen.

The peace of God which passes all understanding, keep your hearts and minds through Christ Jesus, our Lord, amen.

November Newsletter Article


For You formed my inward parts; You covered me in my mother's womb. 
I will praise You, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made;
Marvelous are Your works, and my soul knows very well.
Psalm 139:13-14

            Dear Brothers and sisters in Christ, this past month we hosted a Anthony Horvath, who gave a compelling presentation at Christ The King Lutheran Chapel for the college students, members of our youth group, and some congregational members as well on the topic, “We Chose Life: Why You Should Too.”  As I was listening to his presentation, he raised a number of excellent points about our Christian understanding of life.  In his explanation to the fifth commandment (you shall not kill) in the Small Catechism, Luther writes that, ‘we should fear and love God so that we do not hurt or harm our neighbor in his body, but help and support him in every physical need.’  We believe that all people are our neighbors, especially the unborn.  The following are some of the salient points to Anthony Horvath’s presentation that I wanted to pass along to you.
1.      We live on the front lines in the battle for life.  The prevailing notion most of us have about the abortion issue in society is that it is a political battle waged in courtrooms and elections.  In those spheres we usually see ourselves as tiny, insignificant numbers – our opinion matters, but our own influence is minor.  Horvath agrees that in courtrooms and elections personal influence is slight, but he disagrees that this is ultimately a political or legal battle.  The battle for life is not a matter of statistics, but rather a very personal battle.  It is not a war waged in Washington, DC, but anywhere people find themselves confronted with unexpected pregnancies or pregnancies with complications.  Chances are that you know someone or a couple who have either contemplated or gone through with an abortion.  Perhaps they were grappling with that very question and did not know where to turn for support or advice.  Horvath suggests that one of the most important things Christians can do is be the kind of people others would approach when they face such a difficult decision.  Of course, there are no guarantees that others will listen to our guidance or accept our help, but every life is valuable and it is worth the effort to make ourselves available to those who may be facing these critical decisions.  The front lines of the battle for life are right here – please don’t take it for granted that you could be of valuable service to others struggling over such a question.
2.      Doctors are not infallible.  This is not to say that doctors cannot be trusted – far from it!  Doctors, however, just like pastors, professors, police officers, farmers, etc., can make mistakes.  According to Anthony Horvath, 90% of parents consider terminating a pregnancy if they are offered the option along with the information that their child will or will likely be born with significant health problems, such as Downs Syndrome.  In Mr. Horvath’s case, a genetic screening in the 20th week of his wife’s pregnancy with their daughter revealed that she would almost certainly be born with Spina Bifida, a difficult condition to live with, but until she was born and had lived a few years, there was no way to actually determine the extent to which the condition would effect her life.  In many cases, parents are put on the spot with these critical questions and because the circumstances are often discovered with little or no advanced warning, parents have little chance to educate themselves so that they understand the spectrum of the possible outcomes for their children.  There are, sadly, documented cases of misdiagnoses when it comes to pre-birth genetic screenings, one in particular that was only revealed when the procedure to abort the baby failed and a healthy boy was born.  Even sadder is the fact that we will never know the exact failure rate of such tests because a large portion of these children are aborted.  This is not to say that a correct diagnosis of any kind justifies an abortion, but rather that people who would ordinarily never have considered such a choice sometimes find themselves facing it with little or no warning.  According to Mr. Horvath, the time for making such decisions is not just after being presented with unhappy results of a pregnancy screening; the time to make a decision for life must take place long before parents find themselves thrust into the confusion, sadness, uncertainty, and grief that accompany those circumstances.  Even if the results of the test are 100% correct in diagnosing a serious future health problem, research shows that parents of disabled children overwhelmingly enjoy parenting a disabled child in spite of the drastic changes to their lifestyle that are often required by their children.  Everything we have in this life is a gift from God, and that includes our children.  Don’t wait and hope you never face such a decision; think about it now and talk it over with your spouse, which bring us to the last point.
3.      Victory begins at home.  Here is a provocative statement: “Making abortion illegal is not the most important thing we can do for the lives of unborn children.”  Should people be allowed to electively decide to end the lives of their unborn children?  Of course not, but simply making it illegal does not address the heart of the problem with abortion.  The heart of the problem is that many people believe, for a great number of reasons, that it is morally acceptable for a mother to decide to end the life of her unborn child.  Mr. Horvath said very briefly in his presentation that were everyone to be Christian, there would be no battle over abortion.  Now, to be fair he did not have time to flesh this particular idea out, and at face value it seems a bit outlandish, but he does have a point.  Only a change of heart in society will make people think differently about abortions, and such change can only begin at home, on the real front lines of this battle for life.  Let it not be forgotten among us that seeing these babies born is truly only the beginning of our love for them – we desire above all that they would share with us in the joy of the forgiveness of sins won for us on the cross and the hope we have in Jesus’ resurrection from the dead, and we desire this for their parents as well.  In other words, what we hope for all people is not merely that they have life, but that they have eternal life.  Such hope and faith are given only by the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit uses Christians to reach out and love and care for their neighbors, and this victory most definitely begins at home!  We don’t have to wait until people find themselves in a difficult pregnancy to show them God’s love and seek to help them – the time to show them God’s love in Christ is now. 
            The battle for life is ongoing, and we are all living on the front lines.  There is much to discourage us in the battle, but we look in the wrong place if we endeavor to make a difference through politicians, elections, and legislation.  Instead we must always be reminded that the battle against sin and death has already been fought…and won!  The solution to sin and death is nothing we can work for, persuade others into, or win for ourselves; sin and death were conquered by Jesus’ all-sufficient death on the cross.  In the battle for life, Christ has the victory and gives it to us!
            To him alone be all the glory, forever and ever, Amen.
                        Pastor Bakker

Friday, October 30, 2009

Getting to know the original...

I sometimes feel like I only use this blog when I wish to comment at some length on something taking place within Christianity/society. That's not bad, though, since college students find themselves inundated with information like this all the time in this digital age.

It's not the first time I've heard of the Conservative Bible Project, but I wanted to put in words what I've been thinking about this (and many other) notions going about Bible translation and the accuracy thereof.

While I applaud any attempt to translate the Bible into the English language more accurately than ever before, this attempt is so fundamentally skewed that I would warn Christians, especially conservative Christians, to avoid the product, whenever it appears.

The first statement that must be made in regard to rendering one text in a new language is this: every translation is an interpretation. Not all translations include the interpretations of the translators to the same degree, but all translation definitely involves interpretation, which makes its way into the new text. It's not only not avoidable; it's practically required. It is not possible to make a translation (except, perhaps, if it's just one word) without having to make choices in syntax, voice, mood, tense, etc. - even definition! Just as in English there are multiple words which look the same but mean different things, the same is true in other languages. Often context plays a role in rendering words into another language. It is desirable for us to make and have a translation that doesn't include the interpretive influence of the translator, but it is not possible.

Second, the most literal method to translate something into another language is to attempt a word-for-word translation. This is the best way to minimize the translator's interpretive influence over the text. Unfortunately, this means of translating tends to sacrifice fluidity and readability (especially out loud) in order to stay as close to the original as possible. Readers and hearers must be taught what certain idiomatic phrases meant in the original language, otherwise they can be confusing. This method is probably best exemplified in the New American Standard Bible - probably the most literal translation available - and King James / New King James Versions. NASB requires a grade 12 reading level, and NKJV requires a grade 8 reading level. KJV is a little hard to categorize, considering the archaic language it uses.

Another theory of Bible translation calls for the opposite effort, an attempt to render the Bible in the smoothest reading, most accessible fashion possible. In order to do this, difficult words and passages are rendered using simpler words and passages with the goal of rendering the original concept as clearly as possible. Familiar idioms are substituted for those actually appearing in the original text. God's Word, Good News, and The Living Bible are examples of this kind of translation, which is more accurately described as paraphrase.

It's not as if translators only subscribe to one school of thought or another, but rather that they sit somewhere on a spectrum ranging from word-for-word literalism to thought-for-thought paraphrase. The Revised Standard Version, New International Version, and English Standard Version sit somewhere in the middle - there is definitely an effort made toward a more accurate, word-for-word rendering in English, but at the same time they contain some fairly significant errors. Translation is extremely demanding on the translator regardless of where he is on the spectrum, but the closer you are to a paraphrase, the more the translator's interpretation of the text comes through in the translation.

All of this is fine and good - as a pastor I definitely prefer those translations that do their best to keep the interpretive influence of the translator to a minimum, but I also appreciate that it is not helpful for the Bible to be so hard to read that most people give up when they try. That said, I do not see this Conservative Bible Project as being helpful at all in getting to know the original text. Not only does it come right out and claim to be a 'thought-for-thought' translation (paraphrase) of the original texts, it also reveals that it has a clear interpretive bias - conservatism (whatever that is!)! This is, I'm afraid, the worst kind of translation attempt, not just because of the blatant paraphrase, but even more because of the preconceived notions the translators are carrying into the project.

Take a look for yourself at some of the examples provided at the link above. Eliminating some of Jesus' words because they can be taken as liberal? Eliminating socialist themes and vocabulary from the Bible because they were obviously added later? It's absurd. Anyone who comes to the Bible with these prejudices in place is using their sinful, fallen reason magisterially over Scripture, forming God in their own image and likeness, rather than hearing the Word of God and conforming their lives, as the Spirit grants it, to that Word.

History is full of individuals and societies that sought to choose which parts of the Bible are actually Scripture and which were added later for some other reason. Unfortunately, this is an entirely backward way to look at it. We don't put ourselves over God; God is God, and we are not! Or, as Ireneaus of Lyons used to summarize, 'God makes; man is made.' Only as we are continually being formed into the image and likeness of God (which we only fully receive in eternity) can we have any hope of understanding Holy Scripture, no matter which translation is read!

Thursday, September 17, 2009

A church without the Law?

To some, this is just what they've been looking for all their lives - a church where they can belong without worrying about upholding the Ten Commandments. Think about it - to this author, apparently, things like the Ten Commandments are 'religious', but not necessarily Christian. He claims to have spent a decade of his life miserable, because had been trying to keep those commandments. Now he says that the 'Naked Gospel', a Gospel without the commandments, is a radical way of rethinking the church. Here's my favorite quotation from the article:
"The fruit of the spirit replaces the work of the law in the Christian. And the presence of Christ indwelling us is the reason that we can be free from the entire law," he explains. "We don't even need the moral law if we have Jesus Christ, who is moral."
Isn't that radical? Isn't that revolutionary? Isn't that more biblical than the way it's been done before? Actually, no, on all three accounts!

It's not radical because this HAS been done before - for about as long as the church has been in existence. Marcionism is an early Christian heresy known for avoiding certain Apostolic Scriptures (such as all the Gospels except John, Paul's letters, and the Old Testament) because they offended the prevailing moral sensibilities. It was a Gospel apart from the Law, which sounds eerily similar to what the 'Naked Gospel' appears to promote. There have been many other instances, including the controversy over Gospel Reductionism/the Third Function of the Law in our own circles. This is nothing new.

It's also not revolutionary; it's actually more along the lines of subterfuge. In a clever ruse, the author is not actually doing away with moral guidelines and commands, even though that's what he'd like you to think - he's simply replacing them with the Gospel. The fruit of the spirit, which are, to my understanding, gifts from God according to this new life of faith which has been received from him, are used by this author as a new kind of moral standard. Can you see why anyone would rather have to live by, 'love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control,' instead of, 'you shall have no other gods, remember the sabbath by keeping it holy, honor your father and your mother, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not give false testimony against your neighbor, etc.'? To the current way of thinking, those first gifts/traits/qualities are what we ought to strive for, and those last qualities are oppressive and a big turn off. The problem with that kind of thinking, is that the author has set up a distinction where there is none. He has divided the Word of God into two different revelations - one for then, and another for now. What happens in another two thousand years - does the whole book become irrelevant? The fruit of the spirit and the Ten Commandments are not set up against one another in Scripture - they are complimentary, not mutually exclusive. Further than that, though, he's making the claim that one is the Law, and the other is not the Law. His ruse almost works - you hear the various fruit of the spirit and think it's great, because these are ideological terms that are begging to be defined on an individual basis (another topic maybe for another post), but what it really boils down to, is that you still have a moral standard to which you must live; it may be different in content (more vague), but it's still a moral standard.

Is it more biblical than the way it was done before? Is it even biblical period? No and no - while the Ten Commandments and the fruit of the spirit are definitely biblical, this (so called) new understanding of them is not Biblical. Does that mean that I'm preaching yet another Law to you? Does that mean that I hate the Gospel and that I have no use for it? Does that mean that I hold to salvation by the works of the Law? Absolutely not! I'm positing that this author does not understand the Law and the Gospel, nor how to distinguish one from the other. The Law serves three functions.

1. It sets a standard and carries the threat of punishment to all who would act against it in thoughts, words, or deeds.
2. At the same time, when we consider ourselves in light of this standard, we see that we are fallen and that we need a Savior. That we have received a Savior in Jesus Christ and that he is ours through the free gift of faith is purely Gospel!
3. While it shows us our sin, it also instructs us in the way we should go. The redeemed of the Lord love the Lord and desire to do his will. They want to live the Christian life, but our fallen natures do not know what the Christian life even looks like. The Law tells us this that we may go and do likewise. Will we fail? Of course - and that second function is always present to drive us to repentance and faith in the only one who covers up for our failings in keeping the Law.

I believe this author has been sadly mislead in his understanding of what the church is and what it means to be a Christian. In his desire to be a Christian and have everlasting life, he has somewhere along the way become convinced by the false notion that the substance of Christianity is essentially ethical and moral. This is why he solves the problem of his failure to keep the old Law, the Ten Commandments, by replacing it with a new Law, the fruit of the spirit, which he calls the Gospel.

Friends, we do not hold to the Christian moral code for our hope of salvation. We do not cling to the Christian ethic for eternal life. We subscribe to the Christian FAITH. That's right, the substance of Christianity is Christ, and he connects with us through faith given in his Word and Holy Sacraments. What is tragic about the 'Naked Gospel' is that it's no Gospel at all - it does not actually handle the human problem, which is sin. It tries to excuse it through redefinition. Sin is covered only through the forgiveness Christ won by shedding his blood on the cross. That doesn't free us from the requirements of the Ten Commandments, and it also doesn't free us from failing to live up to them in this fallen world. What forgiveness does, however, is free us from the eternal punishment for our failings. Our price is paid because Christ, the Son of God, has been sacrificed to make our lives eternal.

So do not be swept up in 'new' ideas about a Gospel apart from the Law. They may actually be very old ideas, very bad ideas, and very unbiblical ideas. Law and Gospel both have their functions within Scripture and the church, and the Gospel does not contradict the Law. It doesn't even complement the Law. The most correct way to talk about it is that the Gospel consummates the Law - they go together. When you see your inability to keep the Law, ignore the human tendency to look for a new Law to replace it. Ignore the human tendency to try to find a new Law that you can actually uphold. Instead of trying to beat the Law at its own game, which is impossible, look to Christ. He has overcome the Law on our behalf. We must still follow it and live by it, but through Christ we are forgiven and from an eternal perspective, through Christ it is upheld for us!

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Salespeople

It frustrates me to no end when I'm working in my study on a Tuesday (the one day when we don't have a secretary at the chapel) and I get a sales call on the telephone. I try to be polite, but the fact of the matter is that most of the time it is a waste of both of our time (the caller's and mine) to be talking in the first place.

Most of our supplies, 'overhead', etc. are operated out of Zion Lutheran Church, and aside from that we don't have a lot of money to spend either. When it comes to things like software and publications, we're generally supportive of the things our own church body has worked together to create - CPH is our first choice for materials, we use the Concordia Plan, the Church Extension Fund is where we turned first when we were building. These organizations exist to serve LCMS congregations and because of this they are often better suited than others to cater to our particular needs.

Today I get a telephone call from someone interested in sending us medical insurance. Doesn't tell me where he's calling from, says he's not selling anything, and asks me to confirm the address so they may send information. He gives it to me, and I confirm it, okay so far. Then he asks my name, which I give him (it's on the website, very publicly available so I'm not worried about that). Then he asks my age, and I lie (it's none of his business). Then he asks my wife's age, and I say that I prefer not to give that information out. He asks about children, and again I say that I'd prefer to not share that information. He then asks whether we have insurance (yes), and then which kind. I tell him it's the Concordia plan, which only LCMS congregations may participate in, and that we're very happy with the plan and its coverage. Then he asks if he can send me information from them. I repeat that we're very happy with the insurance we have. He just says, 'Rude Pastor!' and hangs up. Thanks for wasting my time, friend.

Why do these companies believe that churches have money to burn? We don't! If we wanted your stuff we'd have found it. Thanks!

Monday, July 27, 2009

SOLA Conference in Grand Rapids

Last week I attended what was, for me, the best single week event in my life as a Lutheran pastor. I've had days to equal the days I had last week, but never all together like that. Never before has a week so refreshed, so energized, and so excited me about being a Lutheran pastor.

I'm speaking about the Higher Things 'Sola' youth conference held from July 21-24 in Grand Rapids, MI on the campus of Calvin College. This year, as I did last year in St. Louis, MO for the 'Amen' conference, I served as the manager for the Christ on Campus Volunteers (CCVs), the people who help make everything work for the conference by doing a lot of jobs that simply needed to be done. I couldn't have been blessed with a more cheerful and willing staff to work with and they made the week so wonderful.

The highlight of the conference for me was definitely all of the services in the chapel (and Compline in the dorms). Every day began and ended singing the Lord's praises to one another as we received the gifts of forgiveness, life, and salvation through word and sacrament. I know that receiving God's gifts isn't about 'the experience', but it is a profoundly moving thing to be joining with angels and archangels, and all the company of heaven, and 900 fellow young Lutherans in the liturgies of the church, singing with our full voices of the hope we have in our Lord Jesus Christ.

Aside from the services, it was simply great to be around so many young (and some not-so-young) Lutherans who care so much about being Lutheran. In four years, nearly every one of those youth will be in college or university somewhere, some may even be here at CMU. I pray that they continue in the faith as they mature and grow more and more curious about the depths of the riches that are there for them and us in God's Holy Word.

'Dare to be Lutheran' is the Higher Things slogan, and that's what I intend to continue doing with the college students here in the fall, Lord willing!